Pony Pricing Guide
"Of course, all ponies are equally priceless," Moondancer says in a hushed tone that seems to fit the place. "But the fact remains that some ponies frequently visit other herds, while others are very hard to find. Naturally, herd-leaders are eager to meet the harder-to-find ponies. So the "value" of the ponies here is based on how easy or hard they are to find. They are not meant to reflect how beautiful or attractive a particular pony is."
***NOTE: These prices are based on those found in the MLP section of e-Bay, the giant auction site. They are from auctions of a single pony in mint shape.
As of September 28, 1998, I am only counting auctions with pictures. I do not count auctions which had no bidders, but I do include auctions where the reserve has not been met.
Be warned that your ponies may not sell for these prices on your website; e-Bay is a fickle place.
How ponies are listed:
Note that the year on the bottom of your pony's foot is not necessarily the year she was made; it is the year that particular mold was made. If you know your pony's name but not the year she was made, try searching the page with your browser. If you do not know your pony's name, please visit the Pony and Friends section of Dream Valley.
How to figure out pony prices:
After the name of a pony, I will put the average price paid for it. After the price there is a number in parentheses. This shows how many auctions have been averaged into the price.
Year 1
Flat-Footed Collector Ponies
Note that I assume Cotton Candy, Blossom, Minty, Butterscotch, Snuzzle, and Blue Belle to be concave footed unless the seller states otherwise.
Blossom: $3.00 (1)
Cotton Candy: $8.75 (1)
Minty: $13.94 (3)
Blue Belle: $3.75 (2)
Year 2
Concave-Footed Collector Ponies
Note that I assume Cotton Candy, Blossom, Minty, Butterscotch, Snuzzle, and Blue Belle to be concave footed unless the seller states otherwise.
Blossom: $4.46 (4)
Cotton Candy: $4.68 (4)
Blue Belle: $10.50 (1)
"Regular" Ponies (Does not include Collector Ponies, with the exception of Blossom and Cotton Candy.)
Firefly: $2.61 (10)
Medley: $4.53 (4)
Twilight: $8.43 (3)
Glory: $11.89 (6)
Moondancer: $2.82 (3)
Sunbeam: $2.00 (1)
Applejack: $8.67 (6)
Bow Tie: $4.46 (4)
Bubbles: $14.36 (4)
Seashell: $10.51 (7)
Blossom: $4.46 (4)
Cotton Candy: $4.68 (4)
Rainbow Ponies (1st set)
Sunlight: $2.87 (3)
Windy: $11.50 (2)
Moonstone: $5.33 (5)
Parasol: $6.31 (5)
Starshine: $5.88 (2)
Skydancer: $4.12 (3)
Sea Ponies (1st set)
Seawinkle: $4.25 (1)
Sealight: $5.01 (1)
Random Year 2 Ponies
Lemon Drop: $2.25 (1)
Peachy: $2.99 (2)
Sprinkles: $2.27 (1)
Majesty: $10.01 (1)
Spike the dragon (Came with Dream Castle. Yeah, yeah, I know he's not a pony, but . . . ): $10.30 (1)
Baby Ember (lavendar w/lavendar hair, white star): $9.48 (1)
Year 3
"Regular" Ponies, 2nd set
Skyflier: $14.01 (1)
Powder: $8.53 (3)
Sparkler: $3.28 (3)
Gusty: $8.00 (3)
Surprise: $4.87 (3)
Heart Throb: $5.09 (4)
Cherries Jubilee: $4.37 (4)
Tootsie: $5.07 (3)
Lickety Split: $4.25 (2)
Rainbow Ponies (2nd set)
Tickle: $11.64 (2)
Confetti: $16.50 (1)
Trickles: $26.00 (1)
Baby Ponies
Baby Cotton Candy: $4.88 (2)
Baby Blossom: $4.37 (2)
Baby Moondancer: $7.50 (3)
Baby Glory: $6.50 (1)
Baby Firefly: $4.00 (1)
Baby Surprise: $15.50 (1)
Sea Ponies (2nd and, regretably, last set)
Sea Mist: $9.50 (1)
Baby Sea Ponies (without floats unless otherwise noted.)
Sea Shimmer with float: $7.75 (1)
Backstroke: $3.00 (1)
Random Ponies from Year 3
Sundance: $1.84 (6)
Baby Cuddles (non-BBEs): $3.75 (2)
Year 4
So-Soft Ponies (1st set and add-ons to 1st set)
Buttons: $4.82 (2)
Ribbon: $3.12 (2)
Gusty: $7.00 (1)
Lickety Split: $3.00 (1)
Shady: $5.78 (4)
Wind Whistler: $3.62 (2)
Northstar: $3.50 (2)
Paradise: $3.71 (4)
Lofty: $6.12 (2)
Hippity Hop: $8.75 (2)
Scrumptious: $5.72 (2)
Skippity Doo: $4.87 (2)
Cupcake: $5.95 (1)
Twinkle-Eyed Ponies (1st set and add-ons to 1st set)
Fizzy: $5.06 (3)
Galaxy: $6.12 (3)
Masquerade: $5.43 (4)
Whizzer: $3.75 (1)
Sweet Stuff: $4.87 (2)
Speedy: $9.81 (4)
Sweet Pop: $3.25 (1)
Sky Rocket: $4.62 (2)
Baby Ponies with Beddy Bye Eyes
Baby Heart Throb: $2.00 (1)
Baby Lofty: $3.00 (1)
Baby Shady: $3.00 (1)
Baby Ribbon: $3.75 (1)
Baby Lickety Split: $4.25 (2)
Flutter Ponies (1st set)
Note that these are flutter ponies without wings, unless stated otherwise.
Morning Glory: $4.62 (2)
Morning Glory (WITH wings): $42.00 (1)
Peach Blossom: $1.00 (1)
Lily: $5.00 (1)
Pretty 'n Pearly Baby Sea Ponies
Beachcomber: $11.50 (1)
Sea Shimmer: $6.76 (1)
Water Lily: $3.50 (1)
Ripple: $5.00 (1)
Random Ponies from Year 4
Sundance (So-Soft): $5.22 (2)
Baby Sundance (with Beddy Bye eyes): $2.50 (2)
Baby Cuddles (with Beddy Bye Eyes): $2.50 (1)
Party Time: $2.25 (3)
Best Wishes: $2.25 (1)
Celebrate: $2.50 (1)
Baby Sleepy Pie (from the Pony Purse): $7.02 (1)
Year 5
So-Soft Ponies (2nd set)
Taffy: $25.55 (2)
Twinkle-Eyed Ponies (2nd set)
Locket: $8.75 (2)
Mimic: $38.06 (4)
Bright Eyes: $6.95 (1)
Twice as Fancy Ponies (1st set)
Sugarberry: $5.00 (2)
Dancing Butterflies: $7.71 (3)
Up, Up, and Away: $4.87 (2)
Love Melody: $5.76 (3)
Sweet Tooth: $7.87 (3)
Milky Way: $7.00 (2)
Princess Ponies (1st set)
Princess Primrose: $8.50 (3)
Princess Royal Blue: $3.00 (2)
Princess Tiffany: $3.56 (3)
Princess Sparkle: $2.75 (1)
Flutter Ponies (2nd set)
Note that these are flutter ponies without wings, unless stated otherwise.
Wind Drifter: $3.00 (1)
Big Brother Ponies (1st set)
Steamer: $6.25 (2)
Quarterback: $7.00 (2)
4-Speed: $8.00 (2)
Salty: $9.00 (1)
Tex: $15.00 (1)
Baby Ponies with First Tooth
Baby Lickety Split: $3.00 (1)
Baby Bouncy: $3.62 (2)
Baby Tic-Tac-Toe: $4.90 (3)
Newborn Twins (1st set)
Rattles or Tattles: $8.32 (1)
Sniffles: $3.37 (2)
Nibbles: $2.75 (1)
Sea Sparkle Baby Sea Ponies
Sea Spray: $8.20 (1)
Pony Friends (1st set)
Zig Zag: $5.60 (4)
Creamsicle: $5.78 (6)
Kingsley: $5.24 (4)
Spunky: $14.50 (1)
Soft Sleepy Newborns
Hushabye: $31.50 (1)
Pink Dreams: $38.00 (1)
Random Ponies from Year 5
Baby Crumpet (from the Pony Purse): $13.00 (2)
Twice as Fancy Fifi (from the Perm Shoppe): $2.99 (1)
Pillow Talk (from the Slumber Party Giftpack): $21.75 (1)
Baby Nightcap (from the Slumber Party Giftpack): $3.25 (1)
Scoops (from Satin Slipper Sweet Shoppe): $3.09 (5)
Fifi (from the Perm Shoppe): $3.25 (1)
Year 6
Twice as Fancy Ponies (2nd set)
Merriweather: $7.50 (1)
Buttons: $26.75 (2)
Bonnie Bonnets: $7.00 (1)
Munchy: $21.00 (1)
Yum Yum: $6.00 (1)
Princess Ponies (2nd set)
Princess Dawn: $8.00 (1)
Princess Sunbeam: $4.25 (1)
Princess Pristina: $8.00 (1)
Sundae Best Ponies
Peppermint Crunch: $3.75 (4)
Swirly Whirly: $4.93 (3)
Coco Berry: $5.00 (1)
Crunch Berry: $4.87 (2)
Sherbert: $6.37 (2)
Banana Surprise: $3.68 (3)
Brush 'n Grow Ponies
Ringlets: $2.81 (3)
Curly Locks: $7.05 (3)
Twisty Tail: $6.00 (1)
Braided Beauty: $7.00 (1)
Happy Tails Ponies
Tall Tales: $7.50 (1)
Tossles: $4.25 (1)
Tabby: $2.37 (2)
Squeezer: $4.95 (1)
Magic Message Ponies
Mirror Mirror: $3.00 (1)
Big Brother Ponies (2nd set)
Chief: $8.00 (2)
Barnacle: $5.04 (3)
Wig Wam: $5.03 (4)
Peek-a-Boo Baby Ponies
Baby Sweet Stuff: $2.95 (2)
Baby Whirly Twirl: $7.50 (1)
Baby Noddins: $8.00 (1)
Baby Ribbs: $4.25 (1)
Newborn Twin Ponies (2nd set)
Sticky: $4.25 (1)
Big Top: $3.55 (1)
Speckles: $3.25 (1)
Sandcastle: $8.00 (1)
Jabber: $3.00 (1)
Summerwing Ponies (with wings unless otherwise noted.)
Sky Dancer: $10.00 (2)
Flurry: $12.05 (1)
High Flier: $7.50 (6)
Baby Watercolor Sea Ponies
Sweetberry Ponies
Strawberry Surprise: $8.03 (4)
Blueberry Baskets: $6.50 (3)
Boysenberry Pie: $4.58 (4)
Pony Friends (2nd set)
Oakley: $40.88 (1)
Edgar: $7.50 (1)
Random Year 6 Ponies
Year 7
Merry Go Round Ponies
Sparkler: $8.24 (2)
Brilliant Blossom: $3.60 (2)
Diamond Dreams: $10.00 (1)
Sunnybunch: $3.53 (3)
Candy Cane Ponies
Sugar Apple $7.06 (4)
Caramel Crunch: $6.57 (2)
Sparkle Ponies (Assumed to be store-bought unless seller mentions cheek symbol.)
Twinkler: $5.50 (3)
Napper: $4.06 (3)
Sunspot: $5.49 (4)
Sky Rocket: $7.51 (3)
Starhopper: $10.50 (2)
Sunshine Ponies
Mainsail: $3.60 (3)
Beach Ball: $3.59 (3)
Wave Runner: $4.00 (2)
Sea Flower: $3.25 (1)
Perfume Puff Ponies
Sweet Suds: $2.50 (1)
Red Roses: $8.25 (1)
Baby Fancy Pants Ponies
Baby Glider: $3.25 (1)
Playtime Baby Brother Ponies
Baby Paws: $11.00 (2)
Baby Leaper: $20.70 (1)
Baby Waddles: $7.50 (1)
Baby Countdown: $5.57 (3)
Windy Wing Ponies
Cool Breeze: $21.00 (1)
Starry Wings: $9.99 (1)
Sun Glider: $26.00 (1)
Whirly: $22.50 (1)
Flurry: $16.31 (1)
Newborn Ponies
Tappy: $2.50 (2)
Yo Yo: $2.75 (2)
Dangles: $3.00 (1)
Shaggy: $1.75 (1)
Sweetheart Sister Ponies
Dainty: $5.12 (3)
Fancy Flower: $2.50 (2)
Wild Flower: $3.50 (1)
Spring Song: $5.00 (1)
Flowerburst: $8.25 (1)
Frilly Flower: $3.00 (1)
Princess Brush 'n Grow Ponies
Star Gleamer: $5.00 (1)
Sky Lark: $7.50 (1)
Glittering Gem: $5.80 (1)
Dance 'n Prance Ponies
Songster: $2.00 (1)
Twirler: $3.13 (2)
D.J.: $4.00 (1)
Loving Family Ponies
Daddy Apple Delight: $4.25 (1)
Baby Apple Delight: $6.00 (1)
Mommy Bright Bouquet: $3.25 (1)
Daddy Bright Bouquet: $3.25 (1)
Mommy Bright Bouquet: $11.49 (1)
Baby Bright Bouquet: $17.50 (1)
Baby Sweet Celebrations: $8.50 (1)
Baby Ponies and Pretty Pals
Baby Fleecy: $3.00 (1)
Baby Wooly: $10.40 (3)
Baby Nectar: $6.00 (5)
Baby Leafy: $12.00 (2)
Year 8
Tropical Ponies
Pina Colada: $2.00 (1)
Tootie Tails: $5.12 (2)
Sea Breeze: $7.01 (1)
Hula Hula: $2.75 (1)
Rainbow Curl Ponies
Streaky: $5.15 (4)
Raincurl: $3.25 (4)
Stripes: $5.95 (1)
Sweetsteps Ballerina Ponies
Posey Rosey: $1.99 (1)
Drink 'n Wet Baby Ponies
Baby Flicker: $3.00 (1)
Baby Cuddles: $1.75 (1)
Glittery Sweetheart Sister Ponies
Twinkler: $4.52 (2)
Sunblossom: $3.00 (1)
Brightnight: $5.50 (1)
Starflash: $4.00 (2)
Prom Queen Sweetheart Sister Ponies
Baby Sparkle Ponies
Baby Starflower: $4.26 (4)
Baby North Star: $2.50 (2)
Baby Gusty: $4.03 (3)
Baby Firefly: $5.00 (1)
Random Year 8 Ponies
Merry Treat: $6.83 (7)
Pony Bride: $4.50 (4)
Year 9
Rockin' Beat Ponies
Half Note: $3.00 (3)
Sweet Notes: $7.00 (1)
Glow 'n Show Ponies
Star Glow: $9.71 (4)
Bright Glow: $6.27 (6)
Happy Glow: $5.53 (2)
Dazzle Glow: $4.27 (2)
Precious Pocket Ponies (with complete symbol, including object on string, unless other wise noted.)
Bunny Hop: $8.10 (1)
Sweet Pocket: $10.50 (1)
Pretty Ponies
Flower Dream: $2.12 (2)
Baby Rainbow Ponies
Baby Starbow: $4.75 (1)
Baby Rainribbon: $26.00 (1)
Baby Brightbow: $2.50 (1)
Baby Ballerina Ponies
Baby Tippytoes: $3.95 (1)
Teeny Tiny Ponies
Little Giggles: $9.25 (2)
Little Whiskers: $5.00 (1)
Little Tabby: $4.43 (3)
Secret Surprise Ponies
Secret Star (with cape): $13.76 (1)
Secret Beauty (with all accessories--cape, key, and ring): $13.00 (1)
Random Ponies from Year 9
Pink Princess Pony: $2.90 (7)
Year 10
Sweet Talkin' Ponies
Purple: $5.51 (2)
Flower Fantasy Ponies
Flowerbelle: $7.25 (2)
Sweet Blossom: $12.50 (1)
Love Petal: $8.50 (1)
Sweet Kisses Ponies
Lovin' Kisses: $3.00 (1)
Colorswirl Ponies
Lovebeam: $10.25 (1)
Starswirl: $3.50 (1)
Springy: $21.06 (1)
Sundazzle Ponies
Sunsplasher: $3.25 (2)
Sunglory: $3.99 (1)
Paradise Baby Ponies
Baby Palm Tree: $5.50 (2)
Baby Beach Ball: $3.32 (1)
Teeny Tiny Pony Twins
Snookums: $6.50 (1)
Fancy Mermaid Ponies
Soda Sippin' Ponies
Chocolate Delight with her sundae: $12.50 (1)
Random Year 10 Ponies
Bridal Beauty: $6.50 (1)
Birthday Pony: $5.12 (2)
Playset Ponies
Lemon Drop: $2.25 (1)
Peachy: $2.99 (2)
Sprinkles: $2.27 (1)
Baby Cuddles (non-BBEs): $3.75 (2)
Majesty: $10.01 (1)
Spike the dragon (Came with Dream Castle. Yeah, yeah, I know he's not a pony, but . . . ): $10.30 (1)
Sundance (Not So-Soft): $1.84 (5)
Sundance (So-Soft): $5.22 (2)
Baby Sundance (with Beddy Bye eyes): $2.50 (2)
Baby Crumpet (from the Pony Purse): $13.00 (2)
Baby Sleepy Pie (from the Pony Purse): $7.02 (1)
Scoops (from Satin Slipper Sweet Shoppe): $3.09 (5)
Fifi (from the Perm Shoppe): $3.12 (2)
Pillow Talk (from the Slumber Party Giftpack): $21.75 (1)
Baby Nightcap (from the Slumber Party Giftpack): $3.25 (1)
Scoops (from Satin Slipper Sweet Shoppe): $3.09 (5)
Fifi (from the Perm Shoppe): $3.12 (2)
Party Time: $1.50 (2)
Best Wishes: $2.25 (1)
Celebrate: $2.50 (1)
Baby Sleepy Pie (from the Pony Purse): $7.02 (1)
Mail Order Ponies and Special Offer Ponies
Baby Ember (lavendar w/lavendar hair, white star): $14.72 (1)
Baby Ember (pink with lavendar hair): $9.51 (2)
Baby Ember (all blue): $31.00 (1)
December Birthflower--Holly: $2.50 (1)
February Birthflower--Violet: $22.50 (1)
May Birthflower--Lily of the Valley: $10.20 (1)
June Birthflower--Rose: $6.50 (1)
July Birthflower--Water Lily: $9.99 (1)
August Birthflower--Poppy: $12.21 (2)
November Birthflower--Chysamthimum: $26.00 (1)
Li'l Tot: $26.50 (3)
Hollywood (flutter pony without wings): $54.00 (2)
Lucky: $15.50 (1)
Starhopper (mail order Sparkle Pony): $41.00 (1)
Dabble: $40.99 (1)
Baby Sugarcake: $31.00 (1)
Baby Glory (Pearlerized Baby Pony): $23.29 (2)
Baby Firefly (Pearlerized Baby Pony): $31.00 (1)
Baby Blossom (Pearlerized Baby Pony): $41.50 (1)
Baby Surprise (Pearlerized Baby Pony): $20.50 (2)
Goldilocks: $7.62 (3)
Baby Milky Way (TAF Baby): $56.55 (1)
Baby Dancing Butterflies (TAF Baby): $66.00 (1)
Baby Up, Up, and Away (TAF Baby): $46.01 (1)
"Mommy" (came with "Baby", a Fancy Pants Baby.): $20.50 (1)
Rice Krispie Baby Pony: $3.12 (3)
Chuck E. Cheese Baby Pony: $4.74 (3)
White Valentine twin: $6.70 (5)
Purple Valentine twin: $5.50 (1)
Europe-only Ponies
Kiss Curl: 17.25 (1)
Blue Belle (Collector Pony, Made-in-Italy): $9.50 (1)
Applejack (Collector pony pose): $9.99 (1)
Confetti (Parasol's pose): $5.00 (1)
Button Star (non-So-Soft): 31.00 (1)
North Star (non-So-Soft): $18.50 (2)
Wind Whistler (non-So-Soft) (faded hair): $7.50 (1)
Shady (non-So-Soft): $14.50 (2)
Skydancer (in Posey's pose): $33.00 (1)
Baby Gusty (non-BBE): $26.11 (1)
Baby Lemon Drop (Ember's pose): $20.50 (1)
Baby Bow Tie: $17.50 (1)
Thundercloud: $25.00 (1)
Baby Brother Bright Bouquet: $12.50 (1)
Snowdrop: $30.00 (1)
Music Time: $22.00 (2)
Sports Time: $16.50 (2)
Baby Schoolbag (Baby Blossom's pose): $14.38 (1)
Love Token: $26.99 (1)
Mommy Meadowsweet: $41.40 (1)
Baby Sunbright: $16.39 (2)
Nurse Kindheart: $26.50 (1)
Mint on Card/Mint in Box Ponies and Playsets
MOC Applejack: $36.99 (1)
MIB Morning Glory (the flutter pony): $61.50 (1)
MOC Spunky: $30.50 (1)
MOC Boysenberry Pie: $17.50 (1)
MOC Seashore (Watercolor Baby Sea Pony): $9.99 (1)
MOC Misty (Watercolor Baby Sea Pony): $15.50 (1)
MOC Sealight (Watercolor Baby Sea Pony: $14.05 (1)
MIB Baby Graffiti: $23.09 (1)
MIB Baby Noddins: $55.08 (1)
MIB 10th Anniversary Birthday Pony: $50.00 (1)
MOC UK exclusive Party Time outfit: $19.51 (1)
MOC Hartjes-Pony/Herzche-Pony: $37.05 (1)
MOC Bloemetjes-Pony/Blumen-Pony: $36.01 (1)
MOC Konijntjes-Pony/ Kaninchen Pony: $25.89 (1)
